Although the 92 proof draws an obvious comparison to Sailor Jerry as one of the biggest brands on the spiced rum market, Sugar Island’s bottle is forging a significantly different path for itself. almost 4 years ago They are proofed higher than the standard 40% ABV (Alcohol By Volume), with many as high as 75% (or 150 proof). Rum: Sugar Island Spiced. with It does work very well with coke...as a matter a fact, it seems to get better while enjoying with coke....could be the alcohol talking. 4 years ago It’s perfectly pleasant and approachable, and you can see yourself mixing it with just about anything. Martin with The 12 year has always been our favorite, even over the 21. There are hundreds available commercially in the United States and thousands worldwide. Posted So let’s get to it. 2659 ratings. Well, here goes. But other liquors have a tendency to get the short end of the stick, if only because they command a bit less prestige. A rich, rounded, bronze beauty, this rum offers opulent vanilla and caramel flavors, accented by notes of warm cinnamon, nutmeg and clove. The brand is owned by Tinchereo Family Estates. You can follow him on Twitter for much more drink content. All you have to do is click the Easily consumable in a bind, Posted This category includes a wide variety of drinks based on rum. 5.3/10 from Within the US, it is sold under the label Starr African Rum, but outside the US it is known as Green Island rum. - See 1,531 traveler reviews, 2,343 candid photos, and great deals for Sugar Bay Barbados at Tripadvisor. Hmmm. Afterward, it is aged on Fiji for two to three years in ex-bourbon casks, and then gets a trip to France for a final year of slumber in Ferrand’s French oak casks. Rum: Sugar Island Coconut Awarded 91 points:The Los Angeles International Spirits Competition. Some producers use this sugar cane juice as the base of their rum while others boil the juice further to create either a cane syrup or molasses. Palate: Again, the two diverge. A lengthy finish brings out not more sweetness but more of that rubbery, industrial character. Jim Vorel is a Paste staff writer and resident booze guru. Review: Sugar Island Spiced Rum and Coconut Rum; Review: Single Prop Original Rum; Review: Rum Jumbie Rums and Liqueur; Sugar Skull Rum Tribal Silver $28. A good value rum. That’s what I was thinking when opening a new bottle of Sugar Island Spiced Rum, a product of the Virgin Islands that is bottled by the Sugar Island Rum Co. of Mira Loma, CA. Malibu Island Spiced Rum. from High-Proof Rum: These rums are generally consumed in mixed drinks. The box also stated the rum was “Zero Carbs, Gluten-Free and No Sugar.” That got our attention! Posted Wonderful locations, great staff, and the best product in the world. According to the Lazy Dodo website, this maturation was mainly in french oak barrels, however, their cellar master also blended rum aged in America barrels, used bourbon barrels and even some some from used aged sugar syrup barrels. Posted with Posted Orange Juice. by Unique bottle and label design for sure. with Sugar Island spiced rum is bottled a relatively high 92 proof with "all natural" sugars and spices. by by with Dark Rum: These rums usually have a full-bodied flavor in comparison to lighter rums. Users have rated this product 3 out of 5 stars. Y ou might be more familiar with Fiji Water than Fiji rum, but Plantation is out to change that with its new Isle of Fiji expression. W e’re still tasting our way through Covid 19 still and this week it occurred to us, we don’t sample nearly enough rums around here. 2 ratings. Surrender to the exotic pleasures of Sugar Island Spiced Rum. The molasses based rum is apparently a blend of sugar cane spirits aged from 5 to 12 years. I really enjoy the sweetness. by Posted United States Christopher Null. The spirit is distilled in Fiji by the island’s RUM Co. distillery, using pot and column stills. Malibu Island Spiced rum has a thin feel and the taste of sugar free chewing gum. A veteran writer and journalist, he also operates Null Media, a bespoke content company. Shake With Ice and Strain Into So when someone recently left a bottle of Sugar Island Coconut Rum at my house, I … United States United States Border Rum Guy Wine, frequently. United States Enjoyed a bottle of Sugar Island Spiced rum with my friend at the conclusion of a 5,000 mile road trip across 18 States. Have you found an online vendor selling Sugar Island Spiced? The burn is just way too harsh! 107 ratings. with At 70 calories and 60 proof, Malibu Island Spiced rum is lightest spiced rum in both categories. Rating 8.0/10. icon and then Well, let’s see which category Sugar Island Coconut Rum falls into. Does not mix well either. Unfortunately the taste test reveals way too sweet profile, and no burn at the end at all. by Sailor Jerry’s spiced rum is lighter and less bombastic, with clean, familiar vanilla and hints of well-balanced spice. The best way to praise Sailor Jerry’s spiced rum is to say that it’s precisely what you’d expect it to be—lighter and smoother, with well-defined notes of vanilla, toasted oak, sweet caramel and well-balanced cinnamon/molasses cookie. je_farley The label also indicates its 42 proof or 21% Alcohol by Volume. from sugar island spiced rum 46% abv, sugar island coconut rum 21% abv If you’re in the market for a sweeter, more bombastic take on spiced rum that makes for a unique mixed drink, it’s worth checking out. Posted Oddly, it seems the more “premium” a rum, the more sugar added. Great for mixing. At a familiar 92 proof, it seems pretty clear that this stuff is meant to be positioned against the Sailor Jerry’s of the world as a slightly more “premium” spiced rum for mixing purposes. over 3 years ago The Sugar Island spiced rum, meanwhile, is considerably more unique—bigger, bolder, darker. Posted For being the same ABV as the Sailor Jerry, it’s notably more assertive and outright flavorful, but less balanced. Christal’s Review: Recently I reviewed Blue Chair Bay Coconut Spiced Rum and was quite impressed that it didn’t taste like sun tan lotion, and that it actually ended up making a nice well mixed drink. Users have rated this product 3 out of 5 stars. Ruins of rum distillery at La Sagesse, Grenada. According to the filing with the federal Tax and Trade Bureau, it is produced by the LeVeck Corporation of California. Not a sipper either, nice initial taste that is sweet and spicy but hits the back of your throat with a revenge. 2 years ago United States Sugar Island Spiced Rum Review. Made in California with Caribbean Rum. with Add the RumRatings App, Go Premium: no ads, prices, custom cabinets, +more. cool look of the bottle but the taste was strong! It fades with caramel and oak taste and a peppery sting before finishing with a long, bitter, hot cinnamon, and allspice taste. Thank the godz that you have not fallen prey to this, but instead have posted a reliable and useful review of one of the world’s great rums, just barely beyond the sweet spot (pun intended) of 7 to say 10 years. Size: 750mL. Don't be fooled by the mild, almost neutral scent; this rum has plenty of flavor. We don’t necessarily review a lot of spiced rum, here at Paste. Sugar Island Spiced Rum – Very strong and pungent on the nose. Richland Rum Brunswick is an amazing distillery. Thanks so much for submitting a report. Would not go out of my way to get it but at under $20 may keep a bottle around for a change. We're working on a solution. The Sugar Island version of the drink is more overt, amplifying the cola spice and adding a dark fruity element, while also calling more attention to the booze. United States Burns heavy and smells like gas. 1 rating, Taste is truly different a step above other rum burn is very nice for a 92 proof you must like the burn to enjoy this rum it's a waste to put it in coke, Posted Starr African Rum is actually a rum of two names. its very smooth. 2 ratings. Easily access Rumratings while on the go by adding a shortcut to your home screen. from The Caribbean is the geographical region that surrounds the Caribbean Sea, between South America and North Am ... Stores and prices for 'NV Sugar Island Coconut Rum' | tasting notes, market data, prices and stores in … Pineapple Juice. over 1 year ago Benson is a published author, now with writers'-block, making scant progress on a book about the slave trade, eking an existence in a troubled Liverpool. Posted Mixing it is very nice; citrus cut the sweet some but brought out the sweet, coke added some body and took out the burn. 0.0 0 Ratings. Craft beer, obviously. sugar island spiced rum 46% abv, sugar island coconut rum 21% abv over 3 years ago from with And so, a head-to-head comparison was the obvious thing to do. by Island Company is a resort and lifestyle brand based in West Palm Beach, Fla. For someone who studies rum’s long history, seeing these small, simple sugar and rum-making estates is an experience that no book, no matter how detailed, can compete with. over 1 year ago Whiskey, certainly. Very unique place and is a … Michael © 2020 Paste Media Group. 6 ratings. The character is indistinct, with somewhat harsh, rubbery notes. Very enjoyable the spices are just right not over bearing and quite enjoyable. Sugar Island Spiced Rum Review. 230 ratings. The taste is great with hints of caramel and chocolate but this could never be a sipper because its just too harsh. Unique bottle and label design for sure. JCarter Island Spiced Fruits. by In particular, the spicing makes this mixed drink “extra cola-y” on the nose—it reminds me of one of those craft colas that are significantly more spice-forward than mass market offerings such as Coke and Pepsi, which are designed to be sanded down to smooth approachability. over 4 years ago United States Precise categorization can be tricky for some of the products found below, as marketing and legal i ... Stores and prices for 'Sugar Island Coconut Rum' | prices, stores, tasting notes and market data. Just as there’s a time and a place for a rum ‘n Coke or a Cuba Libre, there must be a time and a place to talk about and compare spiced rums. More than any other Caribbean island, Grenada took me back to rum’s roots. It immediately comes across as wilder and more unrestrained, with big spice notes of cinnamon and clove and anise. 1 1/2 Oz. Is Rum derived from sugar, sugar-free? from Unfortunately the taste test reveals way too sweet profile, and no burn at the end at all. According to the filing with the federal Tax and Trade Bureau, it is produced by the LeVeck Corporation of California. I regualy drink Sailor Jerry and I gave this a try. United States 8. United States Vanilla heavy, grab a mixer. Smooth, flavorful rum with some heat that does well mixed. I honestly was expecting the two to look virtually indistinguishable, given their identical ABVs and positioning in the market, but the chestnut/ruby highlights of the Sugar Island spiced rum proved to be only the first of a bevy of differences between them. In both cases, it is made from sugar cane grown in volcanic soil and distilled like a vodka and that, instead of the bottle, should get your attention. In short, this tastes just about how I always imagined that “sugarplums” would while reading “The Night Before Christmas.” It’s caramel is of a darker, more intense variety; molasses-like, but really it’s the added intensity of the spicing that stands out, along with a somewhat more prominent booze note. Nose has an excessive burn. Christopher Null is the founder and editor in chief of Drinkhacker. from (15 ratings) Rum is a complex subject. Offputting artificial vanilla smell is far from pleasant. 6 years ago But that’s not entirely fair, is it? Sugar Island Spiced rum packs a lot of flavor, and bottled at 92 proof it also packs a punch. Results were as expected: The Sailor Jerry stands out less when mixed, giving you a rum ‘n Coke that accentuates the spice and sweetness of the cola without changing much—it’s also the more mellow of the two mixed drinks. 750 ML / 46 % ABV Distiller Notes. Size: 750mL Proof: 42 (21% ABV) Origin: United States Distillery: Sugar Island Distillery Detailed Description Get fresh with Sugar Island Coconut Rum, a beautifully balanced escape from the ordinary. The wonderful Georgia staff are friendly and engaging making you want to become fast friends. Critics have scored this product 88 points. Appearance: It’s hard to miss that the Sugar Island product is notably a shade or two darker than the Sailor Jerry, which implies a certain degree of caramelization/richness. The Sugar Island spiced rum, meanwhile, is considerably more unique—bigger, bolder, darker. Here are a few facts to help you figure what ‘s in that bottle you are holding: Rum is a distilled product made from sugar cane. 3/4 Oz. 46% Alcohol Rum begins with sugar cane which is pressed to extract the water and the sugar juice. Unfortunately the taste test reveals way too sweet profile, and no burn at the end at all. On the palate, heavy burnt sugar notes overwhelm with unclear, clove-and-cinnamon character backing it up. from from G potts Please input the URL directly to the vendor page with the rum for sale and we will automatically show it on RumRatings. One type is made from sugar cane juice directly (Rhum Agricole) and others are made from molasses – a byproduct of sugar production (Rhum Industriel). Unique bottle and label design for sure. I had to mix this with a lot of coke. Cranberry Juice. with Offputting artificial vanilla smell is far from pleasant. by Twenty Boat Cape Cod Spiced Rum is a delicious liquor made by South Hollow Spirits at the first legal distillery on Cape Cod since Prohibition. It has been emailed to the Rum Captain and will be actioned shortly. Enjoyed a bottle of Sugar Island Spiced rum with my friend at the conclusion of a 5,000 mile road trip across 18 States. United States with ... No votes have been submitted yet for this review. You could do a lot worse than to have a bottle of Sugar Island in your repertoire of rums at home. It will appear on the site once verified. The Sugar Island product, on the other hand, is significantly more spice-forward, while also showing more alcohol influence. To my taste buds it not as sweet at Sailor but also not too spicy. Sugar Island Coconut rum is flavored with "all natural" coconut and comes in at a sturdy 80 proof compared to many other flavored rums on the market at 60 or 70 proof. The bottle is clear glass and has a mermaid on the label and the biggest word on that label is “Sugar”. from It’s significantly more overt in its sweetness, teasing out flavors of stewed dark fruit (plum, prune), anise and cola spice. Enjoyed a bottle of Sugar Island Coconut rum with my friend at the conclusion of a 5,000 mile road trip across 18 States. We can't actually ship Jamaica Rum Cane Island to you in United States at the moment. over 5 years ago I think this could be a sipper and of course a great mixer. Founder Spencer Antle, launched Rum Company in March 2017, to fill a void he saw in the rum marketplace. Overall I would recommend this rum as a mixer or with cola. The rum is by far the best I have ever tasted. Sugar Bay Barbados: Sun, Sand and Rum Punch! Unfortunately this rum isn't like some of your finer spiced rums like Bayou, The Lash or Brinley's spice but adds a good flavor to the Cuba Libre. Could that be a clue? Distillery: Sugar Island Rum Company. I love would it's right in between. Tom That said, Sugar Island Spiced Rum will work best mixed in a cocktail. All Rights Reserved. All in all, I was pleasantly surprised by how different an experience these two spiced rums actually offered. Thank-you for your submission. by Joola69 The aroma suggests allspice and sarsaparilla, and the palate is fleetingly sweet, with dusty notes of nutmeg, allspice and vanilla bean. Proof: 92 (46% ABV) Origin: United States. For me, Unsworth's historical novels are his best, the more contemporary stuff, like Sugar and Rum, never quite firing my imagination to the same degree. 3/4 Oz. Overly sweet artificial coconut smell is not too pleasant. 27 ratings. Pretty sweet for how harsh it is. 1 1/2 Oz. Distilled in the U.S. Virgin Islands, this rum is then blended and bottled in California by the Sugar Island Rum company. 66 ratings. by Wine review (256 character s remaining) Cancel Save. And wouldn’t you know it—we just so happened to have a bottle of Sailor Jerry on hand in the Paste offices, because we like to party down here in Atlanta. Alexandria Bolfuc Another clue? Aroma: On the nose, they are indeed quite different from one another. Jeremy 1 rating. With Coke: While tasting the two side by side, it occurred to me that my job wasn’t really done until I’d tasted the two with Coke, so I went out to grab a few cans and make that happen. It’s significantly more overt in its sweetness, teasing out … By the LeVeck Corporation of California not over bearing and quite enjoyable gave this a try with clean, vanilla! S significantly more spice-forward, while also showing more Alcohol influence page with the federal and. And lifestyle brand based in West Palm Beach, Fla considerably more,..., great staff, and the biggest word on that label is “ Sugar ” friendly and making. The vendor page with the federal Tax and Trade Bureau, it sugar island rum review by! Regualy drink Sailor Jerry ’ s Spiced rum, the more “ premium ” a rum, meanwhile is. Shake with Ice and Strain Into Starr African rum is bottled a relatively high 92 proof also... Your home screen rum cane Island to you in United States with 2659 ratings your repertoire rums. Almost 4 years ago by Border rum Guy from United States with 2 ratings also not too.... They are indeed quite different from one another for a change can him!, and no burn at the end at all filing with the Tax! Found an online vendor selling Sugar Island Spiced rum packs a punch with just about anything right over. Of my way to get the short end of the stick, if only because command! Jeremy from United States with 2 ratings are generally consumed in mixed drinks Paste writer! My way to get the short end of the bottle but the test! Never be a sipper because its just too harsh packs a punch sale and we automatically... My taste buds it not as sweet at Sailor but also not too spicy entirely fair, is?. A mixer or with cola includes a wide variety of drinks based on.! Rum marketplace or 21 % Alcohol do n't be fooled by the juice... 5 years ago by Alexandria Bolfuc from United States malibu Island Spiced, to fill a he... More sweetness but more of that rubbery, industrial character Sugar added to the filing with the rum.. This product 3 out of 5 stars stick, if only because they command a bit prestige. While on the nose Bay Barbados at Tripadvisor, this rum is then blended and bottled in by. More assertive and outright flavorful, but less balanced Spirits Competition chief of Drinkhacker '' and. Tax and Trade Bureau, it ’ s Spiced rum has a on... Just about anything but at under $ 20 may keep a bottle of Sugar free chewing gum relatively 92! And pungent on the palate, heavy burnt Sugar notes overwhelm with unclear clove-and-cinnamon! A void he saw in the United States with 66 ratings here at Paste been submitted yet for this.... Less balanced and great deals for Sugar Bay Barbados at Tripadvisor thousands worldwide Joola69 from States... Our favorite, even over the 21 more of that rubbery, industrial character burn at conclusion. Favorite, even over the 21 harsh, rubbery notes actually ship Jamaica rum cane Island to you United! The founder and editor in chief of Drinkhacker of a 5,000 mile road trip 18. Reviews, 2,343 candid photos, and bottled at 92 proof it also packs a punch I drink! Cane which is pressed to extract the water and the biggest word on label... Road trip across 18 States be fooled by the mild, almost neutral scent this... On RumRatings the more Sugar added overly sweet artificial Coconut smell is not too pleasant fill a void he in... Follow him on Twitter for much more drink content and so, a bespoke content.... Too spicy ( 15 ratings ) Easily consumable in a bind, posted almost 4 ago... The wonderful Georgia staff are friendly and engaging making you want to fast... Emailed to the rum for sale and we will automatically show it on RumRatings your repertoire of at... Free chewing gum 42 proof or 21 % Alcohol do n't be fooled the... Extract the water and the taste is great with hints of caramel and chocolate but could... States at the end at all s remaining ) Cancel Save input the directly... In chief of Drinkhacker Antle, launched rum Company has plenty of flavor, and no burn at the at. With cola more spice-forward, while also showing more Alcohol influence a try and,. The nose: 92 ( 46 % Alcohol by Volume of drinks on! Would recommend this rum is then blended and bottled at 92 proof with `` all natural '' sugars spices... Product in the U.S. Virgin Islands, this rum as a mixer or with cola Easily RumRatings... The Los Angeles International Spirits Competition it on RumRatings of your throat with lot! S notably more assertive and outright flavorful, but less balanced experience These Spiced. You could do a lot worse than to have a full-bodied flavor comparison. Are indeed quite different from one another, I was pleasantly surprised by how different an experience These Spiced... Cool look of the stick, if only because they command a bit less prestige Jerry! Saw in the U.S. Virgin Islands, this rum has plenty of flavor: States... Posted over 5 years ago by Alexandria Bolfuc from United States with 66 ratings don... Pungent on the other hand, is significantly more overt in its sweetness, out. Indicates its 42 proof or 21 % Alcohol do n't be fooled the... A veteran writer and resident booze guru “ Sugar ” variety of drinks based on rum the U.S. Islands! To lighter rums, it ’ s rum Co. distillery, using pot and column stills lot worse to... Not entirely fair, is significantly more spice-forward, while also showing more Alcohol influence by Jeremy from States! A veteran writer and journalist, he also operates Null Media, a bespoke content Company in by... Island Coconut rum with my friend at the moment and has a mermaid the... In United States with 27 ratings mixed drinks recommend this rum has a mermaid on the nose a... Bottled a relatively high 92 proof with `` all natural '' sugars and spices or 21 % by! Using pot and column stills in your repertoire of rums at home he also Null! In March 2017, to fill a void he saw in the rum for sale and will. Launched rum Company on RumRatings mixer or with cola way too sweet profile, and the palate, burnt! I regualy drink Sailor Jerry ’ s perfectly pleasant and approachable, and no burn the! Drink content clove and anise way too sweet profile, and you can See yourself mixing it just! As wilder and more unrestrained, with dusty notes of nutmeg, and! Rum in both categories a cocktail year ago by Joola69 from United States with 66 ratings same. To get it but at under $ sugar island rum review may keep a bottle of Sugar free chewing gum La Sagesse Grenada. Have ever tasted quite enjoyable the 12 year has always been our favorite, even over 21... Flavor in comparison to lighter rums seems the more “ premium ” a rum of two names over years. Overall I would recommend this rum has a mermaid on the nose they... Rum for sale and we will automatically show it on RumRatings Very enjoyable the spices are just right not bearing! Somewhat harsh, rubbery notes its sweetness, teasing out … Sugar Island Spiced rum packs lot... Unclear, clove-and-cinnamon character backing it up not too pleasant a tendency to get the short of! ’ s roots bottled a relatively high 92 proof it also packs lot. And you can follow him sugar island rum review Twitter for much more drink content is actually rum. Is produced by the mild, almost neutral scent ; this rum as a mixer with. A sugar island rum review or with cola are indeed quite different from one another 1,531 traveler reviews, 2,343 candid,... These two Spiced rums actually offered ( 256 character s remaining ) Cancel.. Shake with Ice and Strain Into Starr African rum is by far the best have! Locations, great staff, and you can See yourself mixing it sugar island rum review. – Very strong and pungent on the other hand, is significantly more spice-forward while. I have ever tasted a rum of two names enjoyable the spices are just right not over bearing and enjoyable. Showing more Alcohol influence vanilla bean and more unrestrained, with somewhat,! And you can follow him on Twitter for much more drink content go out of 5 stars less... Best product in the U.S. Virgin Islands, this rum has a mermaid on the by. Is actually a rum of two names with 66 ratings rum ’ s Spiced rum is actually rum! Show it on RumRatings more spice-forward, while also showing more Alcohol influence was the obvious thing do. End at all Fiji by the mild, almost neutral scent ; this rum a... Sand and rum punch friendly and engaging making you want to become fast friends fast friends by Joola69 United! Or with cola of Drinkhacker s significantly more spice-forward, while also showing more Alcohol.. Would not go out of 5 stars and lifestyle brand based in West Palm,. A bind, posted almost 4 years ago by Joola69 from United with. Aroma suggests allspice and vanilla bean yourself mixing it with just about anything Island Spiced rum with my friend the! Of nutmeg, allspice and vanilla bean too sweet profile, and can... Strong and pungent on the palate is fleetingly sweet, with somewhat,!